Understanding Human Rights: Labor Rights in a Globalizing World and Gender Rights
Globalization and labor rights
Labour rights are human rights that encompass the right to collective bargaining; the elimination of forced and slave labor; the abolition of child labor; and the eradication of any forms of discrimination at the workplace’’ (Mayer et al. 131).
Globalization is “the growing interpenetration of states, markets, communications, and ideas across borders’’ (Mayer et al. 131). There are two points of view that have created tension between globalization and labor rights.
On the one hand, businesses need to be competitive, thus require labor rights to be a flexible while, on the other side, labor rights have to be guaranteed at all times. This paper seeks to understand how globalization affects the enhancement of labor rights.
Proponents of liberal trade argue that for businesses to be able to offer consumers with quality products at a low price, workers need to more be productive as this will, in turn, spur economic growth and improve the standard of living.
This view suggests that tough labor laws are a hindrance to economic success and better living conditions, which can be improved by the intensification of trade exchanges, which would eventually foster better employment opportunities for workers’’(Mayer et al. 136).
Supporters of solid labor rights argue that while globalization enhances economic growth and working conditions in 3rd world countries, it leads to deterioration of working conditions in developed countries. Globalization demands increased labor flexibility and competitiveness’’ (Mayer et al. 136) this has led to the adoption of labor conditions that violate basic human rights.
Tenants of strong labor rights argue that developing countries compete to offer loose working conditions and minimum salary standards while making unionization of workers particularly difficult’’ (Mayer et al. 135) in order to attract a wider source of foreign investment.
This strategy renders workers in developed countries less competitive thus has to lower their salary demands and at the same time, accept poorer working conditions. Thus labor rights have to be protected by all means in order to overturn this “race to the bottom” (Mayer et al. 138) situation for labor rights.
In developing countries, economic growth is of paramount importance. Thus these governments prioritize economic growth over political freedom. They argue that the principal comparative advantage of their countries resides in the availability of a large pool of cheap surplus labor as well as in the generally lax labor standards’’ (Mayer et al. 138). Thus strict adherence to tough labor laws would interfere with this advantage.
In conclusion, to reverse this, race to the bottom’’(Mayer et al. 137), the two opposing ideologies have to be reconciled in order to enhance economic growth in developing countries while protecting the labor rights already gained in developed countries.
Development of gender rights
Human rights are the fundamental freedoms and rights to which all humans are entitled to simply for being human ’’ (Mayer et al. 156). This paper seeks to trace the development of women’s rights as human rights through three stages; sex-based rights, gender-based rights, and contemporary gender rights.
Sex is the biological distinction of human beings as male or female and was one of the bases on which basic human right was not to be denied. The first stage of gender rights was idealized in the universal declaration of human rights in 1948, which was based on the fact that all human beings possess certain equal and inalienable rights’’ (Mayer et al. 156).
It would have been virtually impossible for women to promote their gender-based rights if universal equality was not captured at this early stage. Three human rights were advocated for as women’s rights; political, economic, and social rights.
Politically women gained the right to vote and stand for public office in elections just like men. Economically women gained the right to earn equal remunerations for equal work. On the social front, women could now enter into marriage freely, start a family, and possessed equal rights during marriage and at its dissolution ’’ (Mayer et al. 156).
Gender can be defined as “those characteristics of men and women that are socially constructed’’ (Mayer et al. 158). A new concept on women’s rights was born in the 1970s where there was a need to “address issues particular to women, resulting from gender differences and cultural and traditional practices’’ (Mayer et al. 168).
This allowed special attention to issues that are unique to women only. Advocates of women’s rights argued that though women legally had all the rights, they faced “structural and systemic constraints’’ (Mayer et al. 160) such that their freedom of choice was hindered.
Contemporary gender rights
These rights were conceptualized at the Beijing +5 conference of 2000 where it was concluded that “the gender rights agenda required readjustment as a result of the changing global economic, technological, and security environments” (Mayer et al. 164). This would allow attention to be paid on modern issues that tend to derail women’s rights such as HIV/AIDS, child rights, rape, and other crimes that are focused on women.
In conclusion, it has been seen that the fight for women’s rights is not a destination but rather a journey that started with the universal declaration of human rights in 1948 and continues till today.
Mayer, Jean Francois, et al. Understanding Human Rights. New York: Nelson, 2008.Print.
Leave a ReplyWant to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!